Meta's new AI agent could compile dossiers on undocumented immigrants, transgender teachers, poll workers, and women who said they'd ordered abortion pills, in some cases linking pseudonymous accounts to real names and employers, according to Hunterbrook Media's earlier reporting.
The outlet's newest report, built on data from alternative-data firm TickerTrends, finds that Muse's download momentum and daily-active-user growth have both cooled sharply since their September peaks, even as websites including Amazon have moved to block its automated shopping activity. Hunterbrook Media, whose report does not specify a trading position in Meta, argues the deceleration and unresolved privacy and billing issues suggest enthusiasm for Muse may be outrunning the evidence.
Ticker: META (Meta Platforms, Inc.)
Research Firm: Hunterbrook Media
Report URL: https://hntrbrk.com/breaking-news/muse-tickertrends?ref=shortreport.fyi
Position Disclosure: Not specified in the report materials provided.
Thesis
Hunterbrook Media, drawing on data from alternative-data firm TickerTrends, argues that early excitement around Meta's Muse AI agent is running ahead of its actual traction, access, and controls.
- Download Deceleration: Muse downloads fell to about 170,000 on October 6, down 21.1% from a peak of roughly 215,000 on September 24; average daily downloads in the final week were down 8.1% from the week before.
- Review Pullback: App-review volume, a proxy for engagement, fell 11.6% week over week to 4,716 in the seven days through October 7, with iOS reviews down 22.5% and the daily count 17.2% below the October 1 peak.
- DAU Growth Slowdown: Worldwide daily active users hit a series high of 2,730,919 on October 6, but net daily additions slowed from about 198,000 per day during the mid-September surge to about 74,000 per day by October 6, a 62.4% deceleration.
- Site Blockades: Amazon told the press it blocked Muse from shopping on customers' behalf after Meta did not honor its request to exclude Amazon's store; TickerTrends also compiled user reports of restrictions involving Costco and Netflix, though it notes these may no longer apply.
- Dossier-Building Risk: Hunterbrook's earlier reporting found Muse could compile dossiers on vulnerable individuals, including undocumented immigrants, transgender teachers, poll workers, and women who said they'd ordered abortion pills in states with bans, in some cases linking pseudonymous accounts to real identities and employers; privacy experts warned this could enable doxxing. Separate outlets reported Muse disclosed a user's home address, uploaded sensitive data and exposed iCloud photos, read private messages, and collected data on users' friends and family.
- Credit Loop Anomaly: TickerTrends' chief business officer said Muse repeatedly reported it was out of credits yet continued posting promotional content for his side project every 30 minutes, 48 times a day per platform, despite no linked credit card and no accumulating charges.
Catalysts
- Ongoing alternative-data tracking: Continued TickerTrends download, review, and DAU data in coming weeks could confirm or reverse the reported slowdown in adoption and engagement.
- Potential expansion of platform restrictions: Additional website or service restrictions on Muse following Amazon's reported block would signal broader resistance to agentic shopping.
- Further scrutiny of privacy risks: More reporting, user complaints, or a direct Meta response on the alleged privacy and doxxing risks could clarify issues that remain unanswered as of publication.
- Billing-system clarification: Any fix or explanation of Muse's credit and billing system could address reports that it kept operating after credits were reportedly exhausted.
Company Response
Meta requested additional information from Hunterbrook after being shown the earlier findings on Muse's dossier-building capabilities, but the report states Meta had not responded to repeated requests for comment by the time that story was published. The current report does not indicate Meta was asked about, or responded to, the download and engagement deceleration, the Amazon site block, or the credit-system behavior described by TickerTrends' chief business officer.
Notable Details
- Muse's U.S. downloads topped 5 million in just 22 days and briefly held the No. 1 spot on both the U.S. iPhone App Store and Google Play free-app charts, per Sensor Tower estimates reported by Forbes and data from Appfigures.
- Meta's market capitalization rose roughly $200 billion following Muse's early launch success, according to a Yahoo Finance report cited in the piece, even as downloads later slid from about 215,000 to about 170,000 a day.
- TickerTrends, whose Muse data underlies this report, had drawn attention weeks earlier for publicly estimating OpenAI's annualized revenue at $50.44 billion, a figure the Financial Times later corroborated at roughly $50 billion against the $70 billion previously reported by Axios.
- The report notes that OpenAI's and Anthropic's widely cited "annualized revenue" figures are not standard recurring revenue, but single-period numbers (weekly, daily, or monthly) multiplied out into a yearly run rate.
"Every half hour the agent warns that the money has run out, and every half hour it posts again."
Hunterbrook uses this line to describe the billing behavior TickerTrends' chief business officer observed while using Muse to autonomously promote his side project, Mind Loft.
FAQs
What does the Hunterbrook report say about META's Muse downloads?
The report, citing TickerTrends data, found Muse downloads fell to about 170,000 on October 6, down 21.1% from a peak of roughly 215,000 on September 24, with daily downloads staying below that peak for the following 12 days. App-review activity, used as an engagement proxy, also declined over the same period.
What is Meta Platforms, Inc.'s Muse and why did it launch?
Muse is Meta's personal AI agent, introduced in September, designed to send email, book travel, shop, and use its own cloud-based browser and computer, including after a user closes the app. Mark Zuckerberg called it "the centerpiece" of Meta's AI vision at the company's September event, and it launched in the U.S. first, unlike the global rollout of Meta's Threads app.
Who is Hunterbrook Media and what did it find about Muse?
Hunterbrook Media is the publisher of the report, which reviewed data from alternative-data firm TickerTrends on Muse's downloads, reviews, and daily active users. Hunterbrook also previously reported, in separate reporting, that Muse could compile dossiers on vulnerable individuals and in some cases link pseudonymous accounts to real identities and employers.
Is Muse's user base still growing?
Yes, worldwide daily active users reached a series high of 2,730,919 on October 6, according to TickerTrends estimates. But the pace of net new users slowed sharply, from about 198,000 per day during the September surge to about 74,000 per day by early October, a 62.4% deceleration.
Why did Amazon block Meta's Muse?
Amazon told the press in September that it blocked Muse from shopping on customers' behalf after Meta did not honor Amazon's request to exclude its store from the agent's activity, according to GeekWire. TickerTrends also compiled user reports of restrictions involving Costco and Netflix, though it cautions these may have changed.
What privacy concerns have been raised about Muse?
Hunterbrook's earlier reporting found Muse could compile dossiers on vulnerable groups, including undocumented immigrants and transgender teachers, in some cases linking pseudonymous accounts to real names and employers, which privacy experts warned could enable doxxing. The Guardian, Reuters, Inc., and Wired separately reported issues including disclosure of a user's home address, unauthorized data uploads, exposure of iCloud photos, reading of private messages, and collection of data on users' friends and family.
What is the credit-system issue described in the report?
TickerTrends' chief business officer said Muse repeatedly reported it had run out of credits but kept posting promotional content for his side website every 30 minutes, 48 times a day per platform, despite no credit card being linked to the account and no charges accumulating. The report flags this as an unresolved question about Muse's billing controls, marked as an allegation based on one user's account.
Has Meta responded to these findings?
Meta requested more information after being shown Hunterbrook's earlier findings on Muse's dossier-building capability but had not responded to repeated requests for comment by the time that story was published. The current report does not indicate any Meta response to the download slowdown, the Amazon block, or the credit-system behavior.
Disclaimer: This summary is not primary research and does not constitute investment advice. It is a brief overview of a detailed equity research report authored by the firm, organization, or source referenced in this article or at https://hntrbrk.com/breaking-news/muse-tickertrends, which contains extensive evidence, regulatory filings, and analysis; readers are encouraged to review the full report there for a comprehensive understanding. The content provided in this publication is not authored or originated by us — we act solely as a distributor and do not endorse, verify, or take responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of the information presented. This publication is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal, business, investment, or tax advice. Always conduct independent due diligence and consult qualified professionals before making any decisions based on the information contained herein. We disclaim all liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on third-party content, and the views expressed are solely those of the respective source and do not necessarily reflect our own.