Carvana: A Father-Son Accounting Grift For The Ages – Hindenburg Research
Hindenburg Research exposes Carvana's fraudulent accounting, revealing massive subprime lending risks, manipulated earnings, and undisclosed related-party transactions threatening the online used car retailer's financial stability.
Hindenburg Research has released a scathing report on Carvana, arguing the online used car retailer's apparent turnaround is actually built on accounting manipulation, risky subprime lending, and undisclosed related-party transactions that artificially inflate earnings.
Stock info:
- Ticker: CVNA (NYSE)
- Position: Hindenburg Research holds short positions in Carvana
Why it matters:
- Carvana's reported profitability is engineered through accounting maneuvers, including reclassifying $390 million in selling costs to artificially inflate gross profit metrics by approximately 34.5%
- $800 million in questionable loan sales to an "unrelated party" appear to be connected to Cerberus Capital, contradicting company disclosures and raising transparency concerns
- 44% of vehicles financed since 2022 carry negative equity, with subprime auto loan delinquencies exceeding 2008 financial crisis levels
- Carvana's key financing partner, Ally Financial, is reducing commitments (from 60% to 35% of loan sales) with their last purchase agreement expiring January 2025
- The Garcia family has sold over $5 billion in stock during periods of engineered earnings beats, suggesting insiders lack confidence in the company's long-term prospects
- Audit committee members have connections to related party DriveTime (owned by CEO's father), raising serious governance concerns and potential conflicts of interest
Between the lines:
- Former Carvana director revealed the company "approved 100% of applicants" beyond minimal compliance checks, creating a toxic loan portfolio
- Carvana inflates "other revenue" through related-party deals with DriveTime, including warranty commissions 58% higher than competitor CarMax
- The company employs "cookie jar accounting" by delaying loan sales to shift income between quarters, creating artificial earnings volatility
- Carvana's loans showing 60+ day delinquencies among "prime" borrowers are 4x higher than industry average (1.3% vs 0.3%)
- Former employees report compromised vehicle reconditioning quality amid cost-cutting initiatives, raising concerns about "lemons" being sold without proper disclosure
- Undisclosed SEC investigations reportedly underway regarding related-party disclosures and accounting practices
FAQs:
What is Hindenburg Research claiming about Carvana?
Hindenburg Research alleges Carvana is engaging in accounting manipulation, hiding related-party transactions, and employing aggressive subprime lending practices to create the illusion of a financial turnaround while insiders cash out billions in stock.
How has Carvana's stock performed recently?
Carvana's stock has experienced extreme volatility, falling from $357 in August 2021 to approximately $3.55 by December 2022 before rebounding dramatically in 2024 with a 284% increase despite ongoing financial concerns.
What specific accounting issues does Hindenburg identify?
The report identifies several accounting issues including: shifting selling costs to SG&A to inflate gross profit metrics, failing to take loss reserves on loan originations, using "cookie jar" accounting to time loan sales for maximum earnings impact, and engaging in questionable related-party transactions that boost reported profitability.
Who controls Carvana and what conflicts of interest exist?
Carvana is controlled by CEO Ernest Garcia III and his father Ernest Garcia II, who have significant ownership in both Carvana and DriveTime. The report identifies multiple related-party transactions between these entities that allegedly lack proper disclosure and independent oversight.
What role does subprime lending play in Carvana's business model?
According to Hindenburg, Carvana heavily relies on originating and selling high-risk subprime auto loans, with approximately 44% of loans in asset-backed securities categorized as non-prime. Many loans fall into "deep subprime" status with average FICO scores between 567-584.
How dependent is Carvana on third-party financing?
The report indicates Carvana is critically dependent on loan sales to third parties, particularly Ally Financial, which constituted about 60% of Carvana's loan sales in 2023 but declined to 35% in 2024. The last purchase agreement with Ally expires in January 2025, creating significant financing uncertainty.
What evidence does Hindenburg provide for its claims?
Hindenburg cites interviews with 49 industry experts and former employees, extensive document reviews including SEC filings and loan securitization reports, lien filings connecting supposedly unrelated parties, and quantitative data from sources like Manheim Price Index and Fitch Ratings.
Disclaimer
This summary is based on a report by Hindenburg Research. For the full, detailed analysis, please refer to the original source material: https://hindenburgresearch.com/carvana/
ShortReport.fyi is not the author or originator of the content provided in this publication. We act solely as a distributor of the content and do not endorse, verify, or take responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of the information presented. Each author retains full ownership and responsibility for their respective content, including any opinions, projections, or analyses expressed therein.
This publication is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal, business, investment, or tax advice. Readers are advised to consult the original source material and seek guidance from qualified professionals before making any decisions based on the information contained herein.
ShortReport.fyi disclaims all liability for any loss or damage arising from reliance on the content provided by third parties. The views expressed in these materials are solely those of the respective authors and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of ShortReport.fyi.